De WaterExpert
← Archive
The WaterExpert · Archive · Parents & trust

Empathy for Parents Who Can't Afford Swimming Lessons: Responsibility and Duty of Care in the Swimming Sector

By Shiva de Winter · May 23, 2024

Originally published on LinkedIn on May 23, 2024 · by Shiva de Winter, The WaterExpert.

Who is actually responsible for swimming lessons?

The question of who is responsible for swimming lessons sparks plenty of debate. Who carries the responsibility, and who foots the bill? Simply saying that parents are responsible in every case may well be true, but it dismisses the feelings of parents who don't feel heard or understood. That's why I want to take a deeper look at swimming lessons, examining not only the responsibility of parents but also the duty of care that rests with the government.

The vital role of swimming lessons

Swimming lessons have been woven into the upbringing of children for years. Some people learned to swim from their parents in a river, others through school, and still others through a public pool, a swimming club or a swim school. Lessons are given in all sorts of places, from hotels and spas to care centres and even the sea. The goal, however, is the same everywhere: to make children able to swim. But being able to swim doesn't automatically mean being safe in the water.

The divisions within the swimming sector

In the Netherlands, there are four types of swimming lesson providers within a widely fragmented sector:

1. Municipal providers: These run entirely on public money and the revenue generated by the pool.

2. Semi-commercial providers: Commercial operators who, through operating subsidies, make near-free use of municipal property, allowing them to turn a profit.

3. Commercial swim schools and pools: These bear all their own costs and revenues, and competing is difficult because of the many subsidies handed to other parties, which allow those parties to keep their monthly costs artificially low. As a result, the contrast in lesson prices can only be described as extreme.

4. Clubs with hundreds of volunteers who week after week look after the thousands of children receiving swimming lessons there.

The cost per lesson across all these providers ranges from €6.50 to well over €30 per lesson. For the average parent it's almost impossible to know what to choose, if they even realise there is a choice at all. For those who can barely make ends meet, it's an unfair road to getting their child into swimming lessons with the provider of their choice.

Financial support for swimming lessons

Alongside the responsibility of parents, those who can't manage financially are often directed to the government. Jeugdfonds Sport en Cultuur and Stichting Leergeld are organisations that can step in where parents can't cover the cost of swimming lessons. It's a noble effort by the government to make funding available to these foundations, so that parents have the option of getting swimming lessons for their child. But because of the restrictions imposed by some municipalities, this becomes a form of "disguised" government subsidy — is that really fair?

These foundations are, in turn, dependent on the municipality and have to comply with the requirements it sets. A municipality can therefore decide whether a foundation is allowed to work with a given swimming lesson provider. In practice, it turns out that some municipalities only want these foundations to work with the municipal pools, which shuts out many other providers. This creates unfairness for both parents and swimming lesson providers.

The role of the government

It's up to The Hague to step in and address this nationwide trend among municipalities. While I personally believe parents are always responsible, I also believe the government must take its own responsibility. Organisations such as Jeugdfonds Sport en Cultuur and Stichting Kinderhulp should not be barred from working with parties other than municipal pools.

Taking responsibility together

Swimming lessons are a concern for all of us. So let's all take our responsibility. Let's show empathy for parents who are struggling financially and make sure that every child gets the chance to learn to swim safely.

Responses and discussion

I invite everyone to share their views and join the discussion on this topic. What do you think of the current situation? What could be better? Let's work together towards a fair and accessible system for swimming lessons in the Netherlands.

More from — Parents & trust

All articles in this theme →

View the in-depth expert articles in the knowledge base →

← Back to the archive